Maxim 7.8.37
Where the crime is, there the punishment should be also.
Ubi culpa est, ibi poena subesse debet.
Source: 6 Coke, 47; Weisman, 92t
Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate
Explanation
Punishment must follow the offender and attach to him personally — it cannot be imposed on an innocent party, and it must be inflicted where the guilt actually lies.
Where this applies
- A man who committed a crime in Texas cannot be tried and punished for it in Ohio — the punishment must follow the crime to where it occurred.
- A company that defrauded customers in California must face penalties in California, not in a state where the company happens to have an office.
- A soldier who committed a theft on a military base is court-martialed at that base rather than at a different installation thousands of miles away.
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 7.8.37 — Where the crime is, there the punishment should be also. — 6 Coke, 47; Weisman, 92t (Ubi culpa est, ibi poena subesse debet.)
Found an error? Suggest a correction →