Maxim 8.8.35
It is improper to give judgment or pass sentence without looking at the whole case.
Source: Dig. 1, 3, 24; Hob. 171a; 8 Coke, 117b; Weisman, 64dd
Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate
Explanation
(English-origin maxim.) A judge must examine the entirety of the evidence and law before rendering judgment — deciding on a partial view of the case is unjust.
Where this applies
- A judge sentences a defendant after hearing only the prosecution's side and ignoring the defense's evidence — the appellate court reverses because the whole case was not considered.
- A court enters a judgment based on one disputed contract clause without examining the rest of the agreement, and the ruling is overturned for incomplete review.
- A jury renders a verdict after the judge excluded key defense evidence — the conviction is reversed because it is improper to judge without looking at the entire case.
Legal domains
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 8.8.35 — It is improper to give judgment or pass sentence without looking at the whole case. — Dig. 1, 3, 24; Hob. 171a; 8 Coke, 117b; Weisman, 64dd
Found an error? Suggest a correction →