Maxim 8.8.27
Sentence is not given upon matters that are not clear.
Source: Jenk. Cent. p. 7, case 9; Weisman, 64k
Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate
Explanation
(English-origin maxim.) A court will not render judgment on a matter that is unclear or unresolved — the facts must be sufficiently established before sentence can be pronounced.
Where this applies
- A judge refuses to convict a defendant when the key evidence is ambiguous and the facts remain genuinely unclear.
- A court declines to enter a verdict in a contract dispute because the terms of the agreement are so vague that neither side's interpretation can be confirmed.
- A jury is instructed that if the evidence leaves reasonable doubt about what happened, they must acquit — judgment cannot rest on uncertainty.
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 8.8.27 — Sentence is not given upon matters that are not clear. — Jenk. Cent. p. 7, case 9; Weisman, 64k
Found an error? Suggest a correction →