Maxim 8.6.16
A suit which is based upon a writing ought not to vary from the writing.
Source: Jenk. Cent. 65; Weisman, 99m
Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate
Explanation
(English-origin maxim.) A suit founded on a written instrument must conform to the terms of that writing — the plaintiff cannot vary from the document upon which he bases his claim.
Where this applies
- A landlord sues to enforce a lease but argues for terms that differ from what the lease actually says — the court holds the landlord to the written document.
- A plaintiff sues on a promissory note but claims the borrower owes more than the note specifies — the court limits recovery to the amount stated in writing.
- A contractor sues to enforce a construction agreement but tries to add work not described in the contract — the suit must conform to the writing it is based on.
Legal domains
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 8.6.16 — A suit which is based upon a writing ought not to vary from the writing. — Jenk. Cent. 65; Weisman, 99m
Found an error? Suggest a correction →