Maxim 7.4.12
The king cannot confer a favour on one subject to the injury and damage of others.
Non potest rex gratiam facere cum injuria et damno aliorum.
Source: 3 Inst. 286; Jackson
Difficulty 1/5 — Foundational
Explanation
Sovereign favor extended to one person cannot lawfully come at the expense of another's rights — the crown's grace must not operate as a trespass upon the people.
Where this applies
- A state grants one large corporation a tax exemption that shifts millions in tax burden onto small businesses and individual taxpayers — the government cannot confer a financial favor on one party at the direct expense of others.
- A city council grants a developer an exclusive zoning variance that blocks neighboring property owners from developing their own land — sovereign favor to one cannot lawfully injure the rights of others.
- A governor pardons a politically connected contractor who defrauded public funds, effectively denying restitution to the taxpayers he stole from — the executive's grace must not operate as a trespass upon the people's rights.
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 7.4.12 — The king cannot confer a favour on one subject to the injury and damage of others. — 3 Inst. 286; Jackson (Non potest rex gratiam facere cum injuria et damno aliorum.)
Found an error? Suggest a correction →