Maxim 12.5.9
The law would rather suffer a mischief than an inconvenience.
Le ley voit plus tost suffer un mischiefe que un inconvenience.
Source: Litt. s. 321; Wharton; Weisman, 71bb
Difficulty 2/5 — Approachable
Explanation
The law tolerates a particular injury to one party sooner than it will permit a general inconvenience affecting the whole system of law. In the American system, however, the rights of the individual are themselves part of systemic integrity — the Bill of Rights exists precisely because the Founders understood that sacrificing individual liberty for systemic convenience without due process of law is itself the greater inconvenience.
Where this applies
- The law would rather tolerate one person's injury than undermine the whole legal system.
- Systemic integrity outweighs individual hardship in the law's calculus.
- A particular mischief is preferred over a general inconvenience that affects everyone.
Legal domains
See also
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 12.5.9 — The law would rather suffer a mischief than an inconvenience. — Litt. s. 321; Wharton; Weisman, 71bb (Le ley voit plus tost suffer un mischiefe que un inconvenience.)
Found an error? Suggest a correction →