Maxim 1.5.348
A matter adjudged.
Res adjudicata.
Source: Snyder v. Trumpbour, 38 N.Y. 355, 361; Angel v. Hollister, Id. 378, 35 Barb. 308; Wharton, III-298; Weisman, 64x; Weisman, 64y
Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate
Explanation
A matter finally decided on its merits by a court of competent jurisdiction is conclusive between the parties and cannot be relitigated — the judgment stands as law between them.
Where this applies
- A company sues its former employee for breach of contract, but the same claim was already decided against the company in a prior lawsuit, and the court dismisses the case because the matter has been adjudged.
- A divorcing spouse tries to relitigate the division of property that was settled in a prior court order, and the judge refuses because the issue is res adjudicata.
- A taxpayer challenges an assessment that was already upheld in a final judgment by the tax court, and the reviewing court declines to reconsider because a matter fully adjudicated between the same parties cannot be reopened.
Legal domains
See also
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 1.5.348 — A matter adjudged. — Snyder v. Trumpbour, 38 N.Y. 355, 361; Angel v. Hollister, Id. 378, 35 Barb. 308; Wharton, III-298; Weisman, 64x; Weisman, 64y (Res adjudicata.)
Found an error? Suggest a correction →