Maxim 9.1.31
Witnesses cannot testify to a negative; they must testify to an affirmative.
Source: 4 Inst. 279; Weisman, 39m
Explanation
(English-origin maxim.) Testimony must be affirmative — a witness can testify to what he saw, heard, or did, but not to what did not happen. Negative proof is inherently weaker than positive proof.
Where this applies
- A witness is asked to swear that an event never happened anywhere at any time.
- Testimony is offered to prove a thing did not occur, rather than to affirm what was actually observed.
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 9.1.31 — Witnesses cannot testify to a negative; they must testify to an affirmative. — 4 Inst. 279; Weisman, 39m
Found an error? Suggest a correction →