Skip to content
NeCede's

Maxim 3.8.13

A minor who is under twelve years of age cannot be outlawed, nor placed without the law, because before such age he is not under any law, nor in decennary.

Minor, qui infra aetatem 12 annorum fuerit, utlegari non potest, nec extra legem poni, quia ante talem aetatem, non est sub lege aliqua.

Source: Co. Litt. 128; Wharton, II-436; Weisman, 80f Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate

Explanation

A child under twelve cannot be outlawed or subjected to the penalties of law, because he is not yet considered to be within the law's jurisdiction — cite this when challenging any legal proceeding brought against a very young child.

Where this applies

  • A prosecutor seeks to charge a ten-year-old with a criminal offense, but the defense argues the child is below the age at which the law recognizes criminal responsibility.
  • A court dismisses proceedings against an eleven-year-old accused of vandalism, holding that a child under twelve cannot be outlawed or subjected to criminal penalties.
  • A school district tries to suspend a nine-year-old and refer him to juvenile court; the defense cites this maxim to argue that a child so young is not yet within the law's punitive jurisdiction.

Legal domains

Cite this maxim

NeCede Max. 3.8.13 — A minor who is under twelve years of age cannot be outlawed, nor placed without the law, because before such age he is not under any law, nor in decennary. — Co. Litt. 128; Wharton, II-436; Weisman, 80f (Minor, qui infra aetatem 12 annorum fuerit, utlegari non potest, nec extra legem poni, quia ante talem aetatem, non est sub lege aliqua.)

Found an error? Suggest a correction →