Maxim 10.7.9
The exception affirms the rule to be the other way.
Source: Bacon, Aph; Weisman, 40a
Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate
Explanation
(English-origin maxim.) The very existence of an exception demonstrates that the rule runs the other way for all cases not excepted — the exception proves the affirmative rule by marking its boundary.
Where this applies
- A statute says "No vehicles in the park, except emergency vehicles" — the exception for emergency vehicles proves the general rule that all other vehicles are banned.
- A lease says "No pets allowed, except service animals" — the exception for service animals affirms the rule that ordinary pets are prohibited.
- A sign says "Employees only beyond this point, except during public tours" — the exception for tours proves that at all other times, only employees may enter.
Legal domains
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 10.7.9 — The exception affirms the rule to be the other way. — Bacon, Aph; Weisman, 40a
Found an error? Suggest a correction →