Maxim 10.2.43
There is no prolixity where there is nothing that can be omitted.
Source: Vaugh. 138; Weisman, 104y
Difficulty 3/5 — Intermediate
Explanation
(English-origin maxim.) A writing is not prolix merely because it is long — if nothing in it can be omitted without loss of meaning, every word is necessary and the length is justified.
Where this applies
- A patent application runs fifty pages, and the examiner complains it's too long — but every paragraph describes a distinct claim element that cannot be removed without losing protection.
- A contract between two companies is forty pages long, and one side argues it should be shorter — but the other side shows that every clause addresses a unique risk, and none can be dropped.
- A witness gives a detailed two-hour deposition, and opposing counsel objects to the length, but every answer addresses a separate factual question that matters to the case.
Legal domains
Cite this maxim
NeCede Max. 10.2.43 — There is no prolixity where there is nothing that can be omitted. — Vaugh. 138; Weisman, 104y
Found an error? Suggest a correction →